Published on November 19, 2026 – Updated on November 19, 2026

Research focus


Michela Limardi

Associate Professor of Economics,
University of Lille

Jordan Loper

Associate Professor of Economics,
CERDI – UCA – CNRS – IRD

Alexandre Volle

Associate Professor of Economics,
University of Pau and the Adour Region (TREE)


As governments multiply regulations to combat climate change, how does civil society react to this tightening of the rules? In a paper published in Ecological Economics, Michela Limardi (University of Lille, LEM), Jordan Loper (Université Clermont Auvergne, CERDI), and Alexandre Volle (University of Pau and the Pays de l'Adour, TREE) analyze the response of non-governmental organizations (NGOs)—actors that operate in the public sphere independently of the state. They show that, far from crowding out citizen action, public climate regulations sustainably stimulate NGO campaigns targeting corporations, turning civil society into an informal enforcement and monitoring mechanism for environmental standards.

An Overlooked Interaction Between Public Policy and Citizen Pressure

In the face of the climate emergency, environmental governance rests on two pillars: on the one hand, public regulations (laws, decrees, standards) enacted by states; on the other hand, "private politics"—that is, direct pressure exerted by non-governmental organizations (NGOs) on corporations through media campaigns, boycotts, or reputational damage.

Until now, the economic literature has often viewed these two mechanisms as substitutes: if the state enforces strict rules, NGO intervention becomes less necessary. The authors propose a theoretical framework highlighting two opposing effects of a new regulation:
  • A cost-reduction effect: New rules provide official legal benchmarks, quantified targets, and transparency obligations that facilitate NGOs' monitoring work and legitimize their demands.
  • A substitution effect: When the state already guarantees compliance with environmental standards, the additional ecological gain an NGO can expect to achieve through its own pressure diminishes.

Executive Climate Decrees Boost NGO Campaigns

To test which of these two mechanisms prevails, the researchers combined monthly data on campaigns by 1,234 NGOs targeting companies across 76 countries between 2010 and 2023 (Sigwatch database) with the exact timeline of national climate regulations (Climate Change Laws of the World database). To isolate a causal effect and prevent NGO mobilization from anticipating parliamentary debates, the analysis focuses on executive actions (decrees, ministerial decisions, orders), whose administrative schedules are far less predictable than those of laws passed by Parliament.

The findings are clear:

•    An immediate and lasting surge: From the very month an executive climate regulation is adopted, the likelihood of an NGO launching a campaign against a company increases significantly. This effect grows over subsequent months, reaching a 42% increase after six months.
•    A documentary leverage effect: Textual analysis of NGO reports confirms that these organizations explicitly rely on new regulatory frameworks (emissions targets, carbon markets, international agreements) to call out corporate practices, both when launching new campaigns and when reinforcing ongoing actions.

A Particularly Pronounced Effect Where State Enforcement Is Weaker

The study also reveals significant disparities depending on the institutional context and the profile of the actors involved:

•    Weakly regulated environments on the front line: The mobilizing effect is markedly stronger in countries with weak initial climate regulation (+38% in campaigns, compared to +13% in already heavily regulated countries). In these contexts, each new rule fills an institutional void and gives NGOs unprecedented leverage to hold private actors accountable.
•    A domestic focus: Mobilization is driven by national-level NGOs targeting domestic companies. Because national regulations apply to firms under local jurisdiction, they provide no additional leverage against foreign corporations.

Public Policy Implications

This research demonstrates that public action and citizen mobilization are complementary. By adopting climate regulations, governments do not merely constrain companies directly; they also equip civil society with monitoring tools that amplify the reach of environmental policies. For policymakers—particularly in countries where state enforcement capacities are limited—establishing clear standards and mandatory environmental data disclosures makes it possible to activate an effective citizen watch at minimal cost.


Published article reference

Limardi, Michela, Jordan Loper & Alexandre Volle (2027). « Climate regulation and civil society activism », Ecological Economics, 253, 109287.
 

Photo © Vincent M.A. Janssen - Pexels, Canva